The National Trial Lawyers
  • Home
    • Meet Our Team
    • Contact Us
    • Mission & Goals
    • FAQ
  • Webinars
  • News
  • Membership Directory
    • Top 100 Map – Civil Plaintiff
    • Top 100 Map – Criminal Defense
    • Top 40 Under 40 Map – Civil Plaintiff
    • Top 40 Under 40 Map – Criminal Defense
  • Top 100
    • Civil Plaintiff Officers / Executive Committee
    • Criminal Defense Officers / Executive Committee
    • Benefits
    • About
    • Top 100 Presidents Message
    • Diplomat
    • Membership Renewal
    • Member Profile Updates
    • Top 100 Badge
  • Top 40
    • Civil Plaintiff Officers / Executive Committee
    • Criminal Defense Officers / Executive Committee
    • Top 40 Under 40 Trial Academy Bootcamp
    • Benefits
    • About
    • Top 40 Presidents Message
    • Membership Renewal
    • Member Profile Updates
    • Top 40 Badge
  • Specialty Assoc
    • About
    • Shop
    • Officers
    • Membership Renewal
    • Member Profile Updates
  • Nominate
    • Top 100
    • Top 40
    • Specialty Association
    • Trial Lawyer Hall of Fame
    • Trial Lawyer of the Year
    • Trial Team of the Year
    • America’s Most Influential Trial Lawyer
    • America’s Most Influential Law Firm
    • Lifetime Achievement Award
  • Shop
  • Magazine
    • A-List
  • Education and Networking Agenda
    • Trial Lawyers Summit
    • Top 40 Under 40 Trial Academy Boot Camp
    • Mass Torts Made Perfect
    • The Lanier Trial Academy Master Class 6.0
    • The Business Of Law
    • Webinars
  • Hall of Fame
    • Trial Lawyer Hall of Fame

NYC Liable for $3 Million for Unsafe Workplace

Posted on January 29, 2015 by Larry Bodine
NYC Liable for $3 Million for Unsafe Workplace

Lopez fell backward and was impaled by an uncapped piece of vertical rebar (steel reinforcement) causing serious life-long injuries.

New York’s Appellate Division Second Department reinstated a  $3 million future pain and suffering award against the New York City Department of Environmental Protection for state labor law violations.

Rafael Lopez filed suit against the city and the department collectively after he was injured while working on the construction site at Newtown Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant. The plant is owned by the City of New York and managed by the New York Department of Environmental Protection.

Lopez fell backward and was impaled by an uncapped piece of vertical rebar (steel reinforcement) causing serious life-long injuries. He required multiple hospitalizations, spinal fusion surgery, and physical therapy.

Due to the nature and extent of Lopez’s injuries, the jury awarded him past and future pain and suffering totaling $5 million.

The city denied that it was liable for the accident and raised issues of comparative negligence, a common defense to a labor law suit.  The city contended the rebar was not an integral part of the work performed on the site.

The defendant was unsuccessful after the Kings County Supreme court granted the plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment on the issue of liability.

On appeal, the city moved for a new trial on the future pain and suffering damages. The court agreed with the original jury award stating the $2,000,000 past pain and suffering did not materially deviate from reasonable compensation and for the same reason the award for $3,000,000 future pain and suffering would be reinstated.  Lopez v. NYC Dept. of Envtl. Prot., 123 A.D.3d 982 (N.Y. App. Div. 2014).

Duty to Protect Employees

Employers have a general duty to provide reasonable and adequate protection to the lives, health, and safety of all persons employed.  N.Y. LAB.  Art 7 §200.

Under the New York Labor Law § 241(6), an employer has a non-delegable duty to provide reasonable and adequate protection to all those employed, especially in areas where construction, excavation and demolition work is performed.

Plaintiff’s counsel also relied on the New York Industrial Code, which provides specific guidelines on how construction areas must be kept safe. The code requires that areas where persons pass through or work shall be kept free dirt, debris, scattered tools, and materials.

Not only should the areas be free from accumulation but also free from sharp projections consistent with the work performed.  Industrial Code § 23-1.7(e)(2).  As is the case in Lopez, any violations of this provision are filed under the Labor Law.

The plaintiff was responsible for showing his injuries were a proximate cause of the defendant’s violation of the Industrial Code and the NY Labor Law.

Although the defendant disputed their liability, the code is clear that employers’ liability is more likely to occur if there are clear violations of safety regulations.

Request for Reduced Damages Award

In addition to its request for a new trial for damages, the defendant requested a reduced future pain and suffering award from $3 million to $1.5 million.

In trial court, Lopez agreed to a remititur of the pain and suffering award. This fact helped the judge determine Lopez was entitled to request up to the full or partial jury award for future pain and suffering.

Generally, if there is a request by the opposing party for a reduced jury award, it may be in the party’s benefit to agree to a reduction. If not, a judge may reduce the jury award  to an amount less than what was previously awarded.

In addition to the reinstated future pain and suffering award, Lopez was awarded past and future lost income, past and future medical expenses, and past pain and suffering.  Lopez received a total jury award of $6.7 million.

The recent opinion may be viewed here. Lopez v. NYC Dept. of Envtl. Prot. 123 A.D.3d 982 (N.Y. App. Div. 2014).

Of counsel for respondent, Brian J. Isaac of Pollack, Pollack, Isaac & De Cicco, LLP New York & Block O’Toole & Murphy.

Fabiani Cohen & Hall, LLP,  Woodbury, NY for appellants, New York Dept of Environmental Protection.

Posted in Blog, Personal Injury

Comments are closed.

News Categories

Read about other Top Jury Verdicts

The New Mexico Supreme Court Upholds $165 Million Damage Awards in a Deadly FedEx Crash

The New Mexico Supreme Court Upholds $165 Million Damage Awards in a Deadly FedEx Crash

The New Mexico Supreme Court on Thursday upheld $165 million of jury awards against FedEx in a wrongful-death lawsuit stemmin[Read More...]
Noom Reaches a $56 Million Class Action Settlement Over Its Autorenewal and Cancellation Policy

Noom Reaches a $56 Million Class Action Settlement Over Its Autorenewal and Cancellation Policy

Weight-loss program Noom has agreed to a $56 million settlement to resolve class action claims regarding its autorenewal and [Read More...]
Virginians Will Receive $489 Million in a Payday Loan Settlement

Virginians Will Receive $489 Million in a Payday Loan Settlement

Online payday loan companies that charged as much as 919% interest will spend $489 million to reimburse some 555,000 borrower[Read More...]
The State of Minnesota Will Pay $1.5 Million to a Man Who Alleged Excessive Force During an Arrest

The State of Minnesota Will Pay $1.5 Million to a Man Who Alleged Excessive Force During an Arrest

Minneapolis has agreed to pay $1.5 million to a man who said police used excessive force when he was arrested during the prot[Read More...]
A $230 Million Settlement Is Reached Over a 2015 Southern California Oil Spill

A $230 Million Settlement Is Reached Over a 2015 Southern California Oil Spill

The owner of an oil pipeline that spewed thousands of barrels of crude oil onto Southern California beaches in 2015 has agree[Read More...]

#LegalNews

@@TheNTLtop100

Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Attorney information and content provided on this website is provided for the benefit of members of The National Trial Lawyers and as a public service by Legal Associations Management, Inc. The website and all data are the property of Legal Associations Management, Inc. Data, including without limitation attorney information and content, on the site may not be mined, sold, or used commercially for any purpose without the explicit written consent of Legal Associations Management, Inc. This site may not be accessed by any automated program for extracting data for any use. By accessing and using the site you agree that you will not develop, support or use software, devices, scripts, robots, or any other means or processes (including crawlers, browser plug-ins and add-ons, or any other technology) to scrape data or otherwise copy profiles and other data. Unauthorized use or attempted unauthorized use of this system may subject you to both civil and criminal penalties.