The National Trial Lawyers
  • Home
    • Meet Our Team
    • Contact Us
    • Mission & Goals
    • FAQ
  • Webinars
  • News
  • Membership Directory
    • Top 100 Map – Civil Plaintiff
    • Top 100 Map – Criminal Defense
    • Top 40 Under 40 Map – Civil Plaintiff
    • Top 40 Under 40 Map – Criminal Defense
  • Top 100
    • Civil Plaintiff Officers / Executive Committee
    • Criminal Defense Officers / Executive Committee
    • Benefits
    • About
    • Top 100 Presidents Message
    • Diplomat
    • Membership Renewal
    • Member Profile Updates
    • Top 100 Badge
  • Top 40
    • Civil Plaintiff Officers / Executive Committee
    • Criminal Defense Officers / Executive Committee
    • Top 40 Under 40 Trial Academy Bootcamp
    • Benefits
    • About
    • Top 40 Presidents Message
    • Membership Renewal
    • Member Profile Updates
    • Top 40 Badge
  • Specialty Assoc
    • About
    • Shop
    • Officers
    • Membership Renewal
    • Member Profile Updates
  • Nominate
    • Top 100
    • Top 40
    • Specialty Association
    • Trial Lawyer Hall of Fame
    • Trial Lawyer of the Year
    • Trial Team of the Year
    • America’s Most Influential Trial Lawyer
    • America’s Most Influential Law Firm
    • Lifetime Achievement Award
  • Shop
  • Magazine
    • A-List
  • Education and Networking Agenda
    • Trial Lawyers Summit
    • Top 40 Under 40 Trial Academy Boot Camp
    • Mass Torts Made Perfect
    • The Lanier Trial Academy Master Class 6.0
    • The Business Of Law
    • Webinars
  • Hall of Fame
    • Trial Lawyer Hall of Fame

Ex-Boyfriend’s Craigslist Revenge Post Protected by the First Amendment

Posted on June 12, 2015 by Eleanor Smith

Ex-Boyfriend’s Craigslist Revenge Post Protected by the First Amendment May a criminal libel statute punish true statements when said for ‘bad motives’ or ‘unjustifiable ends’?

Minnesota’s defamation law was recently struck down as overbroad by the Minnesota Court of Appeals, which recently ruled in favor of the First Amendment right of an ex-boyfriend to post sexually explicit Craigslist ads about an ex-girlfriend.

The messages resulted Timothy Turner’s ex-girlfriend receiving multiple phone calls from men seeking to have sex with her.

Ads offer sex

craigslistIn 2013, Turner listed ads on Craigslist in the “women seeking men” section to humiliate his ex-girlfriend. The ads offered sex and gave her personal information, such as her phone number and the town she lived in. “The ads also included derogatory remarks and racial language,” said Assistant Isanti County Attorney Deanna Natolli, who prosecuted Turner.

Turner, in a second Craigslist ad, even pretended to be his ex-girlfriend’s 17-year-old daughter, again inviting sex, indicating she would be willing to do anything, and providing her personal phone number.

The mother and daughter had no idea what had happened to them until about 6:00AM in the morning when they were receiving text messages stating, “I’ll be there in twenty minutes, just tell me where to go.” Men were sending the mother and daughter videos and pictures of their body parts.

Reprehensible, but unconstitutional

See also:

Defamation Award Overturned in Patient’s Negative Online Review of Doctors

An investigator traced the ads to Turner, who eventually admitted he placed them in retaliation for his relationship suddenly falling apart. After the conviction, Turner appealed, claiming the state’s existing criminal defamation statute is unconstitutional.

The case, State v. Turner has challenged the constitutionality of Minnesota Statute 609.765, a criminal defamation statute. A challenge asserting constitutional overbreadth does not necessarily challenge the facts of a case. While the defendant, Turner, was accused of posting Craigslist sex ads in the names of his ex-girlfriend’s and her daughter’s, including listing their respective cell phone numbers, the amicus briefs submitted in his favor did not require an inquiry into the facts of the case.

Electronic impersonation

In her ruling, Judge Denise Reilly called Turner’s behavior “reprehensible and defamatory,” but found his conviction unconstitutional. The case even prompted a Minnesota legislator, Representative Deb Hilstrom, a Brooklyn Center Democrat and Anoka County prosecutor, to file a bill in the recent session making an electronic impersonation a new felony offense in Minnesota. “The real issue we’re getting at here is when you’re really attempting to cause harm,” Representative Hilstrom told members of the House Public Safety Committee.

The bill is aimed at people who use false personas in social media to harass others and inflict harm to the impersonated person. Fake Twitter accounts designed to be humorous are far different in Rep. Hilstrom’s mind.

“It’s a difference when you are criminally taking on the identity of the person you’re trying to harass, and that’s really what this is about,” Hilstrom explained. “People are taking over minors’ Facebook pages and then posting pornographic videos and pornographic information.”

Legal blogger and professor, Eugene Volokh, submitted a brief on Turner’s behalf, arguing that even true statements can be prosecuted under the Minnesota law, something Judge Reilly said chills free speech. Volokh says, “Whatever the merits of a line between public and private concerns might be for civil liability as to false statements in libel cases, or for review of government employment decisions, that line is too unclear to provide adequate protection for speakers who are risking criminal punishments for true statements.”

Posted in Blog, Civil Rights, Criminal Law / DUI

Comments are closed.

News Categories

Read about other Top Jury Verdicts

The New Mexico Supreme Court Upholds $165 Million Damage Awards in a Deadly FedEx Crash

The New Mexico Supreme Court Upholds $165 Million Damage Awards in a Deadly FedEx Crash

The New Mexico Supreme Court on Thursday upheld $165 million of jury awards against FedEx in a wrongful-death lawsuit stemmin[Read More...]
Noom Reaches a $56 Million Class Action Settlement Over Its Autorenewal and Cancellation Policy

Noom Reaches a $56 Million Class Action Settlement Over Its Autorenewal and Cancellation Policy

Weight-loss program Noom has agreed to a $56 million settlement to resolve class action claims regarding its autorenewal and [Read More...]
Virginians Will Receive $489 Million in a Payday Loan Settlement

Virginians Will Receive $489 Million in a Payday Loan Settlement

Online payday loan companies that charged as much as 919% interest will spend $489 million to reimburse some 555,000 borrower[Read More...]
The State of Minnesota Will Pay $1.5 Million to a Man Who Alleged Excessive Force During an Arrest

The State of Minnesota Will Pay $1.5 Million to a Man Who Alleged Excessive Force During an Arrest

Minneapolis has agreed to pay $1.5 million to a man who said police used excessive force when he was arrested during the prot[Read More...]
A $230 Million Settlement Is Reached Over a 2015 Southern California Oil Spill

A $230 Million Settlement Is Reached Over a 2015 Southern California Oil Spill

The owner of an oil pipeline that spewed thousands of barrels of crude oil onto Southern California beaches in 2015 has agree[Read More...]

#LegalNews

@@TheNTLtop100

Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

Attorney information and content provided on this website is provided for the benefit of members of The National Trial Lawyers and as a public service by Legal Associations Management, Inc. The website and all data are the property of Legal Associations Management, Inc. Data, including without limitation attorney information and content, on the site may not be mined, sold, or used commercially for any purpose without the explicit written consent of Legal Associations Management, Inc. This site may not be accessed by any automated program for extracting data for any use. By accessing and using the site you agree that you will not develop, support or use software, devices, scripts, robots, or any other means or processes (including crawlers, browser plug-ins and add-ons, or any other technology) to scrape data or otherwise copy profiles and other data. Unauthorized use or attempted unauthorized use of this system may subject you to both civil and criminal penalties.